Claim listing not registered

https://staging.restorationlocal.com/places/ohio/cleveland-oh/coreys-restoration/

I start there – I click Business Owner? > Login page with this url:

https://staging.restorationlocal.com/login/?redirect_to=http%3A%2F%2Fstaging.restorationlocal.com%2Fplaces%2Fohio%2Fcleveland-oh%2Fcoreys-restoration%2F%3Fgd_go%3Dclaim

However, if I don’t have a profile to login, I click Create Account

Create Account > account registration page: https://staging.restorationlocal.com/register/

However, once I register – without a page set, I get redirected to the homepage.

How can a user claim their listing with a brand new registration without having to go back and find their listing page again?

I am using the UsersWP plugin, but that doesn’t seem to be helping for these New Users.

For brand new adding listings, it works fine.